Opinion: More than one voice

I’ve avoided watching Caitlyn Jenner’s speech from the ESPYS. Not because I don’t see it as important but I feel overwhelmed by the constant coverage in blogs, magazines, radio and television. On one hand I am glad to see a conversation going on; on the other, I fear it has become one dimensional. 

I’m happy Caitlyn is getting to live life in the real world. To be seen and heard is a powerful validation of ones identity. However. Her’s is not the only story nor is it one common among the trans* community and to hold her up as a poster child for an entire population is to marginalize those who do not meet the publics expectations. (Expectations formed in large part by what they see and hear through a media which has long sought unattainable standards for both men and women.)

I wonder if the conversation would be the same had she not only been a long standing image in reality television and thus guaranteed to draw in eyes, ears, and clicks but if she did not meet the standards of femininity as defined by this same media?

My question now is; what about all of the others? The ones who will never grace a stage or the cover of a magazine? What about the ones who have either slipped or been pushed through the cracks, left to fend for themselves? Those who have sacrificed so much, suffered so much loss, who tread our streets in fear?

I am glad to see a conversation has been started, but we have not heard the whole story, not talked about the reality so many live in every hour of every day.

I don’t want to see their voices, their experiences, their lives drowned out, smothered by an easier to digest narrative.


3 thoughts on “Opinion: More than one voice

  1. I agree. I have only recently seen a rather double-edged article by a transmedicalist / radfem group taking advantage of this situation, claiming that the combination of high-profile attention for a few transwomen compared with the scant attention paid to an impoverished and persecuted majority just goes to prove that transgenderism, rather than being celebrated or accepted, is a sad social disease that should be pitied and if possible eradicated. My instinct is that those voiceless transpeople would not appreciate this form of patronising compassion that seeks to erase their identities, but who is listening to them?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s